• We have updated to the newest version of the forum. Please let us know if you see any issues. And, yes, we know the shoutbox is gone. We'll see about getting it back if they make a newer version.

Easy or hard break in?

Jesse MS3GT

Querulous
So how many people here say to break a car in nice and easy, and how many of you have done the controversial hard break in? I wanna do the hard break in since the theory sounds good to me... But id prefer hearing others results from personal experience.
 
J

JustROLLIN

Guest
I have always gone with the soft/easy break in on my cars, clutches, and things of that nature. Although, even when doing a soft break in, they recommend pushing the vehicle near the redline 2-3 times after about the first 150-200 miles.
 

badfish

New Member
I just stay out of the final 1000 rpms...other than that....drive it like i stole it.

Moderate engine breaking is good for it too.
 
J

JustROLLIN

Guest
I just stay out of the final 1000 rpms...other than that....drive it like i stole it.

Moderate engine breaking is good for it too.
I cant say I agree with anything you have written. Throughout all my training and previous experience, I have never learned/heard anything about engine braking being beneficial to an engine. Not to say it isnt, but I cant say I have ever heard/read that it is.

Nearly everything I have read stated a soft break-in is ideal. :shurgs:
 
J

JustROLLIN

Guest
Maybe Josh, John, or someone else from LSE can step in on this one and share their thoughts???
 

AJ

110 HP of FURY!
Idealy, break the clutch in and then break the motor in, perferably on the dyno if you can. You need to change the oil a couple time in the beginning to be safe, but otherwise, an engine seats the rings best when it's NOT babied out the whole. At least from what I remember from the QPR days.
 
J

JustROLLIN

Guest
Well right, I do recall reading that taking it up to the redline area a few times during break-in is the right thing to do. But, I am pretty sure you want to limit the number of times you do that.
 

dmention7

Hater
Joe, from what I've heard, the reason engine braking is good is that it pulls as strong of a vacuum as possible inside the cylinder. I can't exactly attest as to why that's good... but then again most of the theories I've heard about breaking in an engine talk about WHAT the various methods do to the engine, but never offer a scrap of evidence as to WHY it's beneficial.
 

Jesse MS3GT

Querulous
Well the saleswoman told me not to go above 3500rpm or floor it until the 600 miles were done. Also says in the book not to drive at constant speeds. She said I didnt need my first oil change until 3750 either.. You guys are saying something totally different than what they told me wtf? lol
 

dmention7

Hater
The reason they tell you not to drive at constant speed is that accelerating and decelerating while in gear puts the maximum range of pressure/vacuum loads on the piston rings/cylinder walls. Going smoothly from WOT to zero throttle in your cruising gear is the easiest way to accomplish this while keeping the engine in a mild rpm range. Again, I've heard so many different explanations of why this is desirable (or undesirable) that I can't really comment on that part--just that that's the explanation for not driving at a constant speed.

Honestly, unless you have a firm conviction otherwise (which it sounds like you don't... lol), I'd just follow the manufacturer's instructions and not worry about it. If there was a definitive "best way" to break in an engine (or if it really mattered that much), there wouldn't be so many of these conflicting theories floating around.
 

Jesse MS3GT

Querulous
Well my drive home was 60 miles, so I was varying my speeds/gears alomng the way(60-75mph) then 45-60mph and so on.. I actually went a longer route to go through some stoplights im so paranoid LOL. I did do some wot at low rpms, and also some light jake braking under 4krpm for some vacuum.
 
J

JustROLLIN

Guest
I have never heard anyone call it jake braking before. Jake braking is completely different and utilizes exhaust gases for deceleration, but I dig the terminology.

Most people round her' call it engine braking....
 

Jesse MS3GT

Querulous
looks like I got a final hard break in :rolleyes: On the way to the opener I floored it and my gas pedal got stuck under my mat!! Whoever put my floor mats in didnt use that little hook... That thing is useful! Bounced off the rev limiter when I restarted it(before I noticed what was wrong)

UGH! Now watch I fucked the engine!
 

badfish

New Member
Joe, from what I've heard, the reason engine braking is good is that it pulls as strong of a vacuum as possible inside the cylinder. I can't exactly attest as to why that's good... but then again most of the theories I've heard about breaking in an engine talk about WHAT the various methods do to the engine, but never offer a scrap of evidence as to WHY it's beneficial.
Not sure if this was answered earlier in the thread (i'm still reading through), but the vacuum as well as putting the engine through the vacuum under load is helpful to seat the rings.....
 
Top