• We have updated to the newest version of the forum. Please let us know if you see any issues. And, yes, we know the shoutbox is gone. We'll see about getting it back if they make a newer version.

Mafia 4 - Night 2, Deadline 10/7 9pm

Picklz

SUDO Make me a SAMCH
They are all working fine for me. It's probably eddy's ancient web browser causing issues :lol:
 
Z

Z-licious

Guest
Hey I use IE 8. Don't accuse me of using ancient browsers bro!
 

Picklz

SUDO Make me a SAMCH
IE 8 is almost 4 years old, I'd say that's fairly ancient in terms of technology :) Also lolIE
 

Picklz

SUDO Make me a SAMCH
Sorry for the off topic posts...

Getting back on topic - Jay, are you planning on voting for Day 2? If you had to vote today who would your vote be for and why? I'm a little curious about the fact that you haven't cast a single Vote, and we have about 24 hours before we need to come up with a consensus in order to hopefully avoid what happened on Day 1.
 

dmention7

Hater
Yes, barring any extenuating circumstances, I plan to vote for Day 2.

The only reason I have not case a vote (aside from completely flubbing the vote cutoff time on Day 1) is that I haven't seen a time when it would be advantageous to throw in a "reaction" vote. IMO, that should be done with a more or less clear goal in mind, and I have not seen that opportunity in front of me.

As to who I would vote for--despite going back and forth with Eddy--I have not seen anything clearly scummy come from him yet, and he has put forth a lot of potentially good info. My top two candidates are probably Tom and Nate right now. I don't know that I have any single concrete smoking gun to point to, but I rank them higher for general behavior patterns and that I think they are the two main people whom--if they turned out to be Town--would give a whole lot more insight into who is scum.
 
W

WhiteSpy9

Guest
Had a rough night last night. Couldn't post today. I just speed read through all those posts... 5-6 pages. Here is what I got from direction towards me.

AJ was digging at me for bandwagoning and now he is digging because I didn't vote for Josh?

Does not compute. Make up your mind.

Eddy had a great post about Josh's voting "tactics" or lack there of. This stirred up a vote from Eddy and a bandwagon vote from AJ.

My vote is still with Nate, for the time being. I saw a few posts from him, but nothing that would change my mind. Again, most of my motives for voting Nate are from Day 1. Eddy did make a good post about how Nate always appears "scummy" and that he was in fact town in a previous game. This is something for me to noodle on some more.
 
W

WhiteSpy9

Guest
Smart move.... just don't miss the cut off again this time....

The only reason I have not case a vote (aside from completely flubbing the vote cutoff time on Day 1) is that I haven't seen a time when it would be advantageous to throw in a "reaction" vote. IMO, that should be done with a more or less clear goal in mind, and I have not seen that opportunity in front of me.
 

niterydr

Legendary Status!
Thinking out load for teams based on voting and who I know is townie (no particular order):
Tom/Nate
AJ/Picklz
Jay/Picklz
Andy/Picklz
Nate/Jay
Kris-Eddy/Tom
Kris-Eddy/Jay
Tom/Jay
AJ/Jay
Andy/Jay
AJ/Kris-Eddy

This is of course assuming scum wouldn't vote for scum.
And for those of you insisting I am not a townie:
Josh/Tom
Josh/Jay
Josh/Andy
 
Last edited:

Picklz

SUDO Make me a SAMCH
I don't think it's a real good assumption that Scum won't vote for Scum. I wouldn't expect them to hammer or even probably make a #3/#4 vote, but beyond that I would not put it past them to be an earlier vote in order to try and reduce suspicion.
 
Z

Z-licious

Guest
Tom, why have you been so quiet since I joined the game? You were quite vocal on Day 1, to the point of insisting that JT was a scum. Why haven't you been trying to hunt scum as actively anymore? I think I found all your posts since I joined, which I've quoted below. You haven't been asking any questions and you never really answered my question either. What made you think Nate was not scum back in day 1 when he had 4 votes on him?

Also, you said "I guess I'd like to see more of what he has to say about it." when refering to Nate. Why didn't you ask him anything? Why just sit back and observe? Don't you feel like you should be hunting for scum?

Eddy is scum, obviously. On the off chance he isn't I'm no going to vote him right now because then scum would hammer, we'd get a lynch.... and one more town down.
Eddy, sorry man, my day was a clusterfuck. I'll get to it in the morning.
TBQH, I'm not 100% certain he's not scum any longer, based on the way he's acting right now. I was just sure to the point that JT WAS scum, that I wasn't willing to move my vote off of him. Granted that turned out like shit for town, but what can you do.
Because my Vote would have put Nate 1 vote from the noose. Scum likely would have hammered him before anyone else could unvote. I wasn't willing to risk a hammer two days early at that point, even if it would have likely put scum right on the radar.
Yeah, you're probably right on the current state of things. I'll be honest, upon further review, Nate IS giving off quite the scummy vibe. I'm not sure I'm ready to throw my hat into that ring as of yet, due to my aggregious misfire over the whole JT episode. I guess I'd like to see more of what he has to say about it. My head is between him and Swanny for the moment.
I'm with Eddy. That was a sketchy vote. Though if Eddy and Swanny were working together, that'd be a smart play. Swanny bandwagon votes, Eddy jumps all over him.
 

Picklz

SUDO Make me a SAMCH
Reminder that we should probably start trying to come to a consensus today, so that we can finish up voting during the day tomorrow when people are online. Anyone who does not vote on Day2 is going right to the top of my potential scum list
 
Z

Z-licious

Guest
Thinking out load for teams based on voting and who I know is townie (no particular order):
Tom/Nate
AJ/Picklz
Jay/Picklz
Andy/Picklz
Nate/Jay
Kris-Eddy/Tom
Kris-Eddy/Jay
Tom/Jay
AJ/Jay
Andy/Jay
AJ/Kris-Eddy

This is of course assuming scum wouldn't vote for scum.
And for those of you insisting I am not a townie:
Josh/Tom
Josh/Jay
Josh/Andy


1. How could you KNOW someone is a townie unless you were a cop or scum?

2. It appears as if you don't know anyone is a townie because you listed everyone in the game as possible scum.
 
Z

Z-licious

Guest
Reminder that we should probably start trying to come to a consensus today, so that we can finish up voting during the day tomorrow when people are online. Anyone who does not vote on Day2 is going right to the top of my potential scum list
At this point my money is on Josh or Nate until I can be convinced otherwise.
 

Big Nate

Chaos Engineer
Well following Picklz lead with wanting to figure out a lynch before the last day. At least toget ideas going.

I will say Josh, Picklz, KrisEddy, and Andy are on my list. With Andy being at the top for his bandwagon jumping and Josh right behind him.
 
Top