• We have updated to the newest version of the forum. Please let us know if you see any issues. And, yes, we know the shoutbox is gone. We'll see about getting it back if they make a newer version.

Mafia game 5 - GAME IS ON!

Z

Z-licious

Guest
Current vote count (11/27 9:53 AM)

Picklz [1] - Ben
Dan [0]
Tom [0]
Nate [0]
Andy [2] - Josh, Dan
Josh [1] - Andy
Ben [3] - Nate, Tom, Picklz

Not Voting [0]

With 7 players alive, 4 votes are needed to lynch!

Deadline to vote: 10/31, 9pm.
 

mndsm

I'M OFFENDED!
Apparently. That being said- unvote Ben Not that i'm trying to protect him- I just don't want to give up any time.
 

niterydr

Legendary Status!
Apparently. That being said- unvote Ben Not that i'm trying to protect him- I just don't want to give up any time.
I would leave the vote. I am fairly confident Andy won't switch the vote over to Ben, which would mean Ben would have to vote for himself or Dan or I would have to switch to hammer it home.
 
W

WhiteSpy9

Guest
unvote josh
vote Ben


I would leave the vote. I am fairly confident Andy won't switch the vote over to Ben, which would mean Ben would have to vote for himself or Dan or I would have to switch to hammer it home.
 
Z

Z-licious

Guest
Current vote count (11/28 12:35 PM)

Picklz [1] - Ben
Dan [0]
Tom [0]
Nate [0]
Andy [2] - Josh, Dan
Josh [0]
Ben [3] - Nate, Picklz, Andy

Not Voting [1] - Tom

With 7 players alive, 4 votes are needed to lynch!

Deadline to vote: 10/31, 9pm.
 

Picklz

SUDO Make me a SAMCH
I suspect it may have something to do with the comment before his vote, I can think of one such reason but I don't want to speak for Andy. An explanation would be nice Andy.
 
W

WhiteSpy9

Guest
I thought it was clear by quoting Josh, but here is my reasoning.

To me, Josh's comment was trying to say that I'm not in fact town and I could be working together with Ben.
I switched my vote to clearly contradict this and just put that to rest through actions, instead of words.

It seems to be a common theme this game to just let your voting do the talking. I thought it was pretty clear, sorry for any confusion.

Josh hasn't posted since, so I'm waiting on his reply to this.
I would leave the vote. I am fairly confident Andy won't switch the vote over to Ben, which would mean Ben would have to vote for himself or Dan or I woul
d have to switch to hammer it home.
 

Workdawg

NARWHAL
@Andy - So, do you think Ben is scum then? Is he more scummy than Josh, who seemed to be your previous top pick? If so, what has changed to make you think so. If not, why have you changed your vote?

We've got about 2 days left. Where are we at here? If you are voting, who is it for an why. If you aren't voting, why not? Who do you want to lynch?
 

Picklz

SUDO Make me a SAMCH
I am having a hard time getting a read on anyone right now to be Honest.

Ben is my #1 pick at the moment for scum, I think I've gone over why a number of time in previous posts, I'm not dead set on it so willing to hear arguments elsewhere.

Nate's reduced posting strategy has me concerned as well though the posts he has made give me more of a Town vibe this time around than they did before, not sure if that's good or bad all things considered lol.

Andy - I'm not sure about, there's been a few things that seemed a little scummy - but I like the explanations he's given for the most part, and it seems to make sense to me - what happens with voting the rest of this game should help clarify where Andy stands IMO.

Josh 'seems' like he's trying to be a bit more helpful this game, but I can't really tell and some responses have seemed scum like to me anyway, the explanations for them aren't bad but still, very unsure here.

Dan/Tom - I feel somewhat that they are Town or rather I haven't gotten a real scum vibe from either one. Tom seems to be playing a bit better / more like Town this round, so either he learned some things, or he's scum trying to fly more under the radar this time lol. Dan I think would be a hard one to read either way with his experience so there is that.
 

concealer404

Skanky Escorts LLC
If this is the total of the "much to be learned" from the Gospel of Benrick, then count me as unimpressed.
It's not, but do note that the first stage of the game is all about getting reactions to learn from. I got mine. I've voted accordingly.


By voting early for a target he admits he thought was Town - the only thing Ben did was allow a hammer vote to happen hours before we needed it to, and allow a townie to die. Sure you COULD have suspected that maybe the hammer vote was scum if it came early as it did but A) I don't believe scum would be that silly / careless and B) The person who hammered the vote ended up being Town (and a very valuable town member at that).
You mean i allowed a townie to die? You mean that now that he DID turn out to be town, like i told everyone BEFORE he got lynched, it's bad that i did it? Never mind the fact that he was going to be lynched anyways. I just got it over with, with a VERY good feeling that he was actually town, based purely on your comments prior that a lynching, no matter what, is good for Town on D1.

I will accept 20% of the blame for AJ's death. No more. Don't pass the blame.

Really, we're quoting movie quotes again? Jesus Christ.
Seriously. Everyone is reading way too far into that, and trying way too hard.



Killed one of their own eh?

Vote: Ben
Apparently Picklz has never heard of the third person. Need i go through the thread and point out every time you've referred to "The Town?" If you weren't scum, you'd refer to it as "Us," or maybe "Our Town," right? <rollseyes>

Eeeenteresting... what do you have to say about that, Ben? Are you not one of us innocent townsfolk?
I am in fact one of "you" innocent townsfolk. (Put the "you" in quotes so Picklz doesn't freak out.) To put it simply, yes. I am Town. Vanilla Town, at that.
 
Z

Z-licious

Guest
Current vote count (11/29 11:04 AM)

Picklz [1] - Ben
Dan [0]
Tom [0]
Nate [0]
Andy [2] - Josh, Dan
Josh [1] - Andy
Ben [3] - Nate, Tom, Picklz

Not Voting [0]

With 7 players alive, 4 votes are needed to lynch!

Deadline to vote: 10/31, 9pm.
 
W

WhiteSpy9

Guest
ya... I don't think that is correct....

Current vote count (11/29 11:04 AM)

Picklz [1] - Ben
Dan [0]
Tom [0]
Nate [0]
Andy [2] - Josh, Dan
Josh [1] - Andy
Ben [3] - Nate, Tom, Picklz

Not Voting [0]

With 7 players alive, 4 votes are needed to lynch!

Deadline to vote: 10/31, 9pm.
 

Picklz

SUDO Make me a SAMCH
Not going to lay a vote yet- BUUUUUUT, If Dan had gone down, you would likely be lynched immediately on d2. Self preservation states- kill someone who won't raise more suspicion at me.Think about that.
I believe you are scum because you are one of 5 people who voted for AJ and sense he was not scum and JT was not scum my odds are 33% to hit a scum. If both scum voted.
Current vote count (11/29 11:04 AM)

Picklz [1] - Ben
Dan [0]
Tom [0]
Nate [0]
Andy [2] - Josh, Dan
Josh [1] - Andy
Ben [3] - Nate, Tom, Picklz

Not Voting [0]

With 7 players alive, 4 votes are needed to lynch!

Deadline to vote: 10/31, 9pm.
I think you might want to double check that list - Mr Moderator.
 

Picklz

SUDO Make me a SAMCH
EBWOP: it seems to have multi-quoted for some reason, probably from a prior multi-quote that didn't clear, anyway I just meant to quote the latest vote update, which is incorrect.
 

niterydr

Legendary Status!
I thought it was clear by quoting Josh, but here is my reasoning.

To me, Josh's comment was trying to say that I'm not in fact town and I could be working together with Ben.
I switched my vote to clearly contradict this and just put that to rest through actions, instead of words.

It seems to be a common theme this game to just let your voting do the talking. I thought it was pretty clear, sorry for any confusion.

Josh hasn't posted since, so I'm waiting on his reply to this.
I had thought you were scum and were partners with Ben. That is indeed my theory. With you switching your vote it shows that either:
1) You are indeed a townie and believe Ben is a scum member
2) A scum member and sacrificing Ben, a scum, to hide.
3) Scum and Ben is town, thus it is an easy move for you to make.
 

concealer404

Skanky Escorts LLC
I had thought you were scum and were partners with Ben. That is indeed my theory. With you switching your vote it shows that either:
1) You are indeed a townie and believe Ben is a scum member
2) A scum member and sacrificing Ben, a scum, to hide.
3) Scum and Ben is town, thus it is an easy move for you to make.
By Nate math, this means that Andy has a 66.7% chance of being Scum. Do i need to change my vote? :D
 

Big Nate

Chaos Engineer
If there are two scum who voted for a lynch day one then it is still a 33% chance.

Percentages don't change unless other variables are installed.
 
Top