• We have updated to the newest version of the forum. Please let us know if you see any issues. And, yes, we know the shoutbox is gone. We'll see about getting it back if they make a newer version.

Mafia game 5 - GAME IS ON!

W

WhiteSpy9

Guest
The advantage is that we collectively have come to an agreement of who to lynch. You voted for Nate, clearly that indicates you feel at some level he is scum, when you pull your vote, but don't explain until TODAY why you voted for Nate in the first place, there is no reason to think you wouldn't have re-voted for him.Again, my comments there are about what transpired BEFORE your explanation today. What I'm trying to say is... its odd that you vote for someone... pull your vote and don't explain why until you get heat for it.

Obviously we have different opinons on play style, I'm ok with a day ending early if we are going to move forward collectively and in agreement as a group.
This clearly gets me labelled as "bandwagon" every game... but screw it. It's a game and that is how I see to play it.

mndsm said:
VOTE ANDY You wondering why I wouldn't pull the EARLY d2 lynch vote... WTF? What possible explanation could be there for that? Unless I had a GUARANTEED lock vote on a scum, there is 0% advantage to doing that.
Click to expand...
 
W

WhiteSpy9

Guest
Josh isn't around.... Tom obviously isn't going to vote for him now.

See my previous post. I prefer to move with the crowd, if it makes sense to me

Vote Nate
 
mndsm

mndsm

I'M OFFENDED!
WhiteSpy9 said:
The advantage is that we collectively have come to an agreement of who to lynch. You voted for Nate, clearly that indicates you feel at some level he is scum, when you pull your vote, but don't explain until TODAY why you voted for Nate in the first place, there is no reason to think you wouldn't have re-voted for him.Again, my comments there are about what transpired BEFORE your explanation today. What I'm trying to say is... its odd that you vote for someone... pull your vote and don't explain why until you get heat for it.

Obviously we have different opinons on play style, I'm ok with a day ending early if we are going to move forward collectively and in agreement as a group.
This clearly gets me labelled as "bandwagon" every game... but screw it. It's a game and that is how I see to play it.
Click to expand...
I pulled my vote for Nate because he was L-1... did you not see that part?
 
Z

Z-licious

Guest
As the sun sets on MNMazda town Nate is the clear choice to be lynched. "Why you such a scummy scum scum, Nate?" "Why'd you kill JT?! We don't care if he's dumb!" Nate is led to the gallows to hang. As he is hung, he mouths the words "I am town". Sure enough they check his pockets and there's a note saying "VANILLA TOWNIE".

Nate - Vanilla Townie has been lynched!

The thread is now closed and night will last approximately 48 hrs.
Scum can resume communication via PM.
If you are a power role, make sure your action is submitted by 11/2 @ 9 AM.

Nights are declared to be 48 hours, btw I am willing to open the game early if ALL players PM me requesting it AND all actions have been submitted.



Final vote count (Day 2)

Picklz [0]
Dan [0]
Tom [0]
Nate [4] - Dan, Ben, Picklz, Andy
Andy [2] - Josh, Tom
Josh [0]
Ben [1] - Nate

Not Voting [0]
 
Z

Z-licious

Guest
As the sun rises everyone gathers at the town square. Everyone but Josh that is. A quick search of his house reveals that he has been shot in the face.

Josh Vanilla Townie is dead!


It is now Day 3... you have until 11/7 at 9pm to discuss and vote for a lynch.

With 5 players alive, 3 are required to lynch.
 
Workdawg

Workdawg

NARWHAL
Well then... firstly... NO ONE VOTE. With two scum left and only 3 votes needed to lynch, if one town votes, the two scum can jump on the wagon and lynch immediately.
 
Workdawg

Workdawg

NARWHAL
Secondly, if we lynch wrong this time, scum wins... so it's come down to it. At this point, we need to roleclaim. Any and all information NEEDS to be used to make sure that we get scum this time. Last time I played, the best way to do this was via the "popcorn method." It works like this:

The person who is determined to be scummiest by the group must claim their role. When they do, they also name another person. That person must then claim their role. It continues until everyone has claimed... then you discuss the results. Typically this ends up with the most scummy people claiming first and the most town claiming last (as the most town person is more likely to be truthful).

If you don't know what I mean by roleclaim... I don't just mean "I am town"... I mean your specific role, whether that is Vanilla townie or one of the power roles.

Right now, I'm really not sure who the fuck is scum. I guess I would vote for Ben or Tom to claim first.
 
W

WhiteSpy9

Guest
Interesting strategy.... so we all vote and the top pick has to flourish their role?
I guess that could at least get the discussion going again.

I agree with Ben being on the top of the scum list at this point. He was L-1 at one point, so I don't feel that really needs to be re-hashed.


Workdawg said:
Secondly, if we lynch wrong this time, scum wins... so it's come down to it. At this point, we need to roleclaim. Any and all information NEEDS to be used to make sure that we get scum this time. Last time I played, the best way to do this was via the "popcorn method." It works like this:

The person who is determined to be scummiest by the group must claim their role. When they do, they also name another person. That person must then claim their role. It continues until everyone has claimed... then you discuss the results. Typically this ends up with the most scummy people claiming first and the most town claiming last (as the most town person is more likely to be truthful).

If you don't know what I mean by roleclaim... I don't just mean "I am town"... I mean your specific role, whether that is Vanilla townie or one of the power roles.

Right now, I'm really not sure who the fuck is scum. I guess I would vote for Ben or Tom to claim first.
Click to expand...
 
mndsm

mndsm

I'M OFFENDED!
Andy has moved to the top of my list. Reason? Bandwagon vote or not, he early hammered the d2 lynch. Knowing that it meant the death of two town (lynch and NK) it's a move I would have made going into d3.
 
C

concealer404

Skanky Escorts LLC
mndsm said:
Andy has moved to the top of my list. Reason? Bandwagon vote or not, he early hammered the d2 lynch. Knowing that it meant the death of two town (lynch and NK) it's a move I would have made going into d3.
Click to expand...
Hold up.

How could you have possibly known that?
 
mndsm

mndsm

I'M OFFENDED!
I didn't. However- he would have. The count going into that lynch was 5/2. If you're scum, you already know who town and scum are, you just have to kill them. So, Nate sitting L -1, Andy comes in and hammers. That puts the count to 4/2. NK means the count is 3/2. We're on d3, and if scum gets another town kill, we lose. It's allllll math.
 
Workdawg

Workdawg

NARWHAL
concealer404 said:
Smells like an excuse being made for Picklz before he needs one. He was online yesterday. You talked to him in the chatbox.
Click to expand...
I know he was planning on going up north to do some hunting this weekend. I'm pretty sure he left yesterday, but not sure when.

concealer404 said:
So instead of "Knowing that it meant," you meant to type "If i knew that it meant?"
Click to expand...
I think the way he worded it makes sense. I was thinking Andy was coming up the list because of that as well... I will have to review the end of the day again.
 
Picklz

Picklz

SUDO Make me a SAMCH
Sorry up north hunting and my cell service is pretty limited. I'll try and get a somewhat intelligent post made asap. I'll be home Monday though.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top