• We have updated to the newest version of the forum. Please let us know if you see any issues. And, yes, we know the shoutbox is gone. We'll see about getting it back if they make a newer version.

Obamanomics Explained

AJ

110 HP of FURY!
Got this from another local forum. Pretty good!

--

Here's a simple analogy for our tax system, kinda puts things in perspective.

BAR STOOL ECONOMICS (Obamanomics)

Suppose that every day, ten men go out for beer and the bill for all ten comes to $100.

If they paid their bill the way we pay our taxes, it would go something like this:

The first four men (the poorest) would pay nothing.
The fifth would pay $1.
The sixth would pay $3.
The seventh would pay $7.
The eighth would pay $12.
The ninth would pay $18.
The tenth man (the richest) would pay $59.

So, that's what they decided to do. The ten men drank in the bar every day and seemed quite happy with the arrangement, until one day, the owner threw them a curve.

Since you are all such good customers, he said, I'm going to reduce the cost of your daily beer by $20.

Drinks for the ten now cost just $80.
The group still wanted to pay their bill the way we pay our taxes so the first four men were unaffected. They would still drink for free.

But what about the other six men - the paying customers?
How could they divide the $20 windfall so that everyone would get his 'fair share?'

They realized that $20 divided by six is $3.33. But if they subtracted that from everybody's share, then the fifth man and the sixth man would each end up being paid to drink his beer. So, the bar owner suggested that it would be fair to reduce each man's bill by roughly the same amount, and he proceeded to work out the amounts each should pay! And so:

The fifth man, like the first four, now paid nothing (100% savings).
The sixth now paid $2 instead of $3 (33%savings).
The seventh now pay $5 instead of $7 (28%savings).
The eighth now paid $9 instead of $12 (25% savings).
The ninth now paid $14 instead of $18 (22% savings).
The tenth now paid $49 in stead o f $5 9 (16% savings).
Each of the six was better off than before. And the first
four continued to drink for free. But once outside the restaurant, the men began to compare their savings.

'I only got a dollar out of the $20, 'declared the sixth man.
He pointed to the tenth man, 'but he got $10!'

'Yeah, that's right,' exclaimed the fifth man. 'I only saved a dollar, too. It's unfair that he got ten times more than I!'

'That's true!!' shouted the seventh man.. 'Why should he get $10 back when I got only two? The wealthy get all the breaks!'

'Wait a minute,' yelled the first four men in unison.. 'We
didn't get anything at all. The system exploits the poor!'

The nine men surrounded the tenth and beat him up.

The next night the tenth man did n't show up for drinks, so the nine sat down an d had beers without him. But when it came time to pay the bill, they discovered something important. They didn't have enough
money between all of them for even half of the bill!

And that, boys and girls, journalists and college professors,
is how our tax system works. The people who pay the highest taxes get
the most benefit from a tax reduction. Tax them too much, attack them
for being wealthy, and they just may not show up anymore. In fact, they might
start drinking overseas where the atmosphere is somewhat friendlier!


David R. Kamerschen, Ph.D.
Professor of Economics, University of Georgia

For those who understand, no explanation is needed !
For those who do not understand, no explanation is possible !
 

Workdawg

NARWHAL
But the poor guys are still getting a free ride paid for by the rich guys.

Also, isn't that more Bushonomics? Tax cuts for the rich that'll trickle down to help out the poor?
 
Last edited:

dmention7

Hater
I think that's the point. The people at the bottom are angry at the people at the top for a perceived inequality in tax breaks, when in fact they are being subsidized by the people at the top.
 

ZoomZoom Diva

New Member
The one problem with taking the rates at face value is there are many forms of income that are exempt from being called income and ways of sheltering income from taxation that while many of the richest do pay well over their fair share, there are others who do not.
 

Stealthgator

New Member
I know everybody likes to think Taxes are a simple thing but there are a hole host of socio-economic (sp?) reasons why some people pay less and others pay more.
 
S

spek1098

Guest
Much is lost in this debate about taxes. Yes, in essences, that is how it works. The fact is that a democracy is inherently socialistic in nature and that is the mechanism that allows it to thrive the way it has. The rich have gained the most from living in our democratic society and have the most to lose if it collapses. So guess how they mitigate the risk of that happening? They pay higher taxes to support the systems that maintain the society that will continue to benefit them at a much higher rate then the majority of the people. Yes the lower half more or less gets a free ride when it comes to taxes. But guess what, that lower half is the men and women working in business and buying the products that are generating the high incomes of the upper 10%. Start taxing them at the same rate as the rich and they will not be generating nearly as much wealth because the same raise in taxes for the lower class will affect there level of spend much more dramatically then if it was applied to just the wealthy; thus damaging the wealthy more then if the taxes were just applied to them.

Yes no one should be getting a complete free ride, and I think the welfare reform of the '90s fixed much of that. That fact is if you are working and helping build someone’s business, you are providing for the growth of society as well as helping by generating taxes indirectly.
 

LASERBLUE135

Active Member
that is a cute story, but I have another one.

Imagine that you are going to watch an "income parade". You are "average hieght" meaning that you are "average income". You expect that because you are average (5 ft 10 inches tall) that 1/2 of people will be shorter/poorer than you and that 1/2 will be taller/richer than you. You COULD expect that people will start at 0 inches and grow to double your size. That would be "fair" in many ethical senses.

Let's imagine that every working American walking by in an hour-long parade. Let us also assume that everyone's height is proportional to his or her salary. The first ones to pass, you can not even see. They are in fact underground and in debt. For a full 7 minutes you would see NOTHING. Then for a very long while, those underemployed working at odd jobs, are only an inch high. Next the spectators would see the fully employed making minimum wage, but they would be only a foot high. For the rest of the first half hour, the parade goers would observe most of America's skilled workers, and they would still be only about three feet tall.

Only after 45 minutes would the spectators begin to see people as tall as they are—those in the upper class. During the last six minutes rich Americans in our economic parade would be shooting up in height at an astounding rate. This is because nearly half the money made in America goes to a mere 10 percent of the population. Doctors and lawyers would be at least 20 feet tall, and CEOs and top financial managers would be looming above us from 100 to 500 feet. Finally, the America's billionaires would be marching by in shoes whose soles are hundreds of feet thick.

This is NOT how it is in other countries. It is a bizzarly American trait. So our tax system having bizzar disparity should not suprise anyone. And the rich continue to get vastly richer than ever before. So the tax inequality will not change, it will in fact grow much more to the high income side.

Why on earth would the rich "not show up for drinks"??? When they will come to the bar with more money than they had the night before!
 

LASERBLUE135

Active Member
quote from above..."In fact, they might
start drinking overseas where the atmosphere is somewhat friendlier!"


the point of my story...
AHHH! but the atmoshere in America is the most friendly place on earth! They have absolutely no reason to drink overseas.
 

ZoomZoom Diva

New Member
I know everybody likes to think Taxes are a simple thing but there are a hole host of socio-economic (sp?) reasons why some people pay less and others pay more.
Taxes should be and can be a simple thing. I would say the reasons for the complication and the paying different percentages of income in taxes are far more political than socioeconomic.

Laser, I see little fairness or ethics in somehow saying income should go from zero to 200% of the average. I also question the model than working Americans make a negative income, even if they are in debt. The only people I can think of are business owners operating at a loss. I also question the number of Americans working for less than minimum wage and the like, particuarly saying the make approximately $1,000 a year. Doctors and Lawyers making at least $250,000 a year...

Also, "billionaire" is a measure of wealth, not income.

The atmosphere in America is not the most friendly place on earth for taxes. There are many places, in the Caribbean for example, that welcome the wealthy as tax havens.
 

YSOSLO

is the word, beotch
Oh please.
Not a very compelling argument Josh. C'mon, what have YOU got to back up your take on things.



I'm with Kyle in a way, because no matter how much the rich choose to bitch about taxes, many of them still rest their heads on a pillow in a much nicer house than any of the "regular people" will ever have a chance at in their lifetime and the idea that they'd have the opportunity to do the same thing in a different country is something I'd like to hear more about. Sure you'll see plenty of rich guys from around the world that are heads of industry or inherited fortunes, but once you cut out the top 1%, there are still a LOT of very rich people in the U.S. that wouldn't have the opportunity or the freedom to get where they are today in a different country.
 
M

mazdamn02

Guest
Not a very compelling argument Josh. C'mon, what have YOU got to back up your take on things.
This just happened to post under your reply, its not necessarily aimed at you.

I believe that it should be a FLAT tax. That is all. Why should the rich subsidize the poor? I think that poor people need something other then a comprehensive tax plan to make them not poor.
 

ZoomZoom Diva

New Member
This just happened to post under your reply, its not necessarily aimed at you.

I believe that it should be a FLAT tax. That is all. Why should the rich subsidize the poor? I think that poor people need something other then a comprehensive tax plan to make them not poor.
AGREED!
 

YSOSLO

is the word, beotch
Rich people LOVE the flat tax, because there's a lot more left after 20% of $200,000/yr compared to $40,000/yr in gross income, but the government needs an ever-increasing amount of tax income to sustain the country which would require the flat tax percentage to be so high that most of the poor wouldn't have anything left. And I guarantee there aren't any rich employers that are going to be willing to take a pay cut to enable their employees to make a living wage, so the only thing left is a staggered tax structure.

Personally I'm a bigger fan of consumption taxes. Raise the sales tax to 20% or so with no exemptions including food or clothing, and then eliminate all other taxes. And no charging tax on used goods. Once something is sold, it's fuckin' SOLD, so the government only gets their cut once. We'd probably see a lot of changes happen pretty quickly in all aspects of our daily lives if this were the case. People would have to pay the price LITERALLY if they decide to overindulge in any aspect of their lives. Of course, corporations would still want to be exempt from paying their share because they're "creating jobs" and other lame excuses, which would enable them to provide awesome "perks" to the higher-ups in every business throughout the country allowing them to still keep their status as untouchable. No exemptions. Period. And still tariffs on all imports, so companies aren't tempted to try to move any aspect of their business overseas. Basically flatten out the playing field, so the Average Joe doesn't feel like they're fighting an uphill battle every day of their life.
 
M

mazdamn02

Guest
Rich people LOVE the flat tax, because there's a lot more left after 20% of $200,000/yr compared to $40,000/yr in gross income, but the government needs an ever-increasing amount of tax income to sustain the country which would require the flat tax percentage to be so high that most of the poor wouldn't have anything left. And I guarantee there aren't any rich employers that are going to be willing to take a pay cut to enable their employees to make a living wage, so the only thing left is a staggered tax structure.

Personally I'm a bigger fan of consumption taxes. Raise the sales tax to 20% or so with no exemptions including food or clothing, and then eliminate all other taxes. And no charging tax on used goods. Once something is sold, it's fuckin' SOLD, so the government only gets their cut once. We'd probably see a lot of changes happen pretty quickly in all aspects of our daily lives if this were the case. People would have to pay the price LITERALLY if they decide to overindulge in any aspect of their lives. Of course, corporations would still want to be exempt from paying their share because they're "creating jobs" and other lame excuses, which would enable them to provide awesome "perks" to the higher-ups in every business throughout the country allowing them to still keep their status as untouchable. No exemptions. Period. And still tariffs on all imports, so companies aren't tempted to try to move any aspect of their business overseas. Basically flatten out the playing field, so the Average Joe doesn't feel like they're fighting an uphill battle every day of their life.
2 things:

#1 I'm pretty sure I just crapped myself, 20% sales tax?! WTF!

#2 This would do exactly the opposite effect of what you're intending, the burden would then be on the poor to pay for the taxes: If a rich man wants to buy a chevy silverado for $30k and a guy that makes $50k a year wants to buy that same truck, they both pay the same thing, irregardless of income! See where I'm going?

:signs066:
 

YSOSLO

is the word, beotch
yes, but 20% is only on NEW vehicles (and I just used 20 bc it's got to be high enough to compensate for the lack of income tax, property tax etc) so the take home pay etc would be the full Net Income for everyone...usually taxed at 25-33% right off the bat by your employer anyway. See what I mean?...more money in your pocket means more money available to pay for consumption taxes and since the rich are able to buy more, drive vehicles with worse mpg and things like that, the tax income will work itself out. Keep in mind, the whole tariffs on any products coming into the U.S. would also apply to people vacationing or living overseas that might try to ship or bring things back into the U.S. NO loopholes for the wealthy to skirt their share. It would dramatically change the whole economic landscape.
 

ZoomZoom Diva

New Member
1) The expansion of income over time would provide government with additional tax revenue as time continues, in exactly the same way it currently does with fixed progressive tax brackets that move with inflation.

2) The amount of income tax to replace the current income tax would be approximately 10%. If we used an income tax to replace all federal taxes, the people would become more aware of the real taxes they are paying and do something about our overbloated and wasteful system of governments.

3) I am opposed to consumption-based taxes because they are discriminatory. The percentage of income a person pays in taxes should have nothing to do with the choices they make. Whether someone chooses to indulge or scrimp is none of the government's business and therefore taxation should not be based on it.

Such taxation would also be detrimental to the economy after a burst of spending to get while the getting is good before the tax becomes effective. The used products loophole is a MAJOR way to dodge taxes and it also will not tax the black market or barter transactions.

My last issue with consumption based taxation is that it is far more difficult for an individual to calculate the actual tax burden, where it is simple to do so with an income tax. Transparency is critical.

4) Tariffs generally only serve to hurt the consumer by making them pay more for things, and to encourage overproduction and production in areas we do not have a comparative advantage. It is better to have free markets for imports to your country and to freely export your goods to other nations.

If the Average Joe is feeling like he has an uphill battle every day of his life, it is often because he is not taking responsibility for his own situation and condition in life and empowering himself to security.
 

LASERBLUE135

Active Member
First of all I like the idea of consumptive taxes. 20% sales tax, sure, bring it on. You are only taxed on what you BUY/SPEND. It gets rid of all the BS complications of the tax system. but it will NEVER be this way, the government doesn't want it because it's too easy to hide the money.

Taxes should be and can be a simple thing. I would say the reasons for the complication and the paying different percentages of income in taxes are far more political than socioeconomic.
2nd I'm taking an ethics/morality class AND a tax class right now.
Americans have only had income tax since 1913. So its a relatively new concept. And tax on the wealthyest americans used to be 91%!!!!!!!!!!!!! Our current tax system is actually set up to REDUCE the amount that the wealthy pay:) TRUE. As they used to pay the majority of their money to the government.

I also question the model than working Americans make a negative income, even if they are in debt. The only people I can think of are business owners operating at a loss.
yes, 7% of working people take a loss as a business owner, you are correct.

Laser, I see little fairness or ethics in somehow saying income should go from zero to 200% of the average.

The atmosphere in America is not the most friendly place on earth for taxes. There are many places, in the Caribbean for example, that welcome the wealthy as tax havens.
The ethics is very clear. In the minds of the VAST MAJORITY of those who are considered the greatest moral thinkers of all time, income should be equally spread as wide and as fairly as possible. In a corner of the ethical world there are "libertarians" who make a strong case that MORALLY we should only expect others not to interfear with us.

The Caribean is a TAX HAVEN, meaning that they are great places to HIDE your money, not MAKE your money. America makes wealthy people richer and richer than any other place in the world. That's why they would never leave.

The bottom line is this: America is set up to benifit the very wealthy. There income is growing by leaps and bounds while everyone esles is flatlining and shrinking. The tax system is set up to somewhat balance what is "fair" and "ethical". While it may not be "fair" to pay more tax, it is "ethical" to use that money to benifit the less advantaged.
 
S

spek1098

Guest
The atmosphere in America is not the most friendly place on earth for taxes. There are many places, in the Caribbean for example, that welcome the wealthy as tax havens.
No not for taxes, but it is the most friendly for businesses to thrive in, and that's why America has been the world's economic engine since WW2. It's always for selfish reasons people want to dramatic change the tax structure; so they can shift their responsibility for the society they live in onto someone else. I don't understand why people would want to make such a dramatic change to our society. This system, with its tax structure and the relative level of taxes we are currently and historically been at, has created an environment for business to thrive continuously over the last 70 years. To upset this that significantly would not be good for America.

Consumption and flat taxes sound great in principle, but they are both regressive and affect lower incomes more dramatically then they do the upper class. Cars are a great example: for you and me 20% more on a $25,000 car would more then like make us think twice about that car, but the rich, many of which have no problem dumping $100,000 - $200,000 on a car or 10, another 20% would not make much of a difference or stop them from buying it. Plus we live in a society with an economic system based on consumption. I don't want to live through the depression that a switch to a tax system like that would throw us into.
 
Top